About the Greysheet Marketplace

Catalog

Group

Series

Category Icon

CAC

Grading Authority

Sale Format

Seller

Sort By

Greysheet Marketplace: Buffalo Nickels (1913–1938)

Catalog

Group

Series

Category Icon

CAC

Grading Authority

Sale Format

Seller

Sort By

Grid View

List View

1936 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/11/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
NGC MS67
9
CAC
1938-D/D 5c Buffalo MS

Auction Ends: 8/17/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
30
CAC
1938-D 5c Buffalo MS

Auction Ends: 8/17/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
26
CAC
1938-D 5c Buffalo MS

Auction Ends: 8/17/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
21
CAC
1937-D 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/17/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
NGC MS67
30
eBay
eBay
Sponsored
1937-D 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/11/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
NGC MS66
6
1936 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/11/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
NGC MS66
4
1935-S 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/11/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS66
4
1926 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/11/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS66
6
1913 5c Buffalo, Type 1 MS

Auction Ends: 8/11/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS66
9
CAC
1913-S 5c Buffalo, Type 1 MS

Auction Ends: 8/17/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS66
21
David Lawrence Rare Coins
David Lawrence Rare Coins
Sponsored
CAC
1935-S 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/17/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS66
33
CAC
1913 5c Buffalo, Type 1 MS

Auction Ends: 8/17/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS66
17
CAC
1913 5c Buffalo, Type 2 MS

Auction Ends: 8/17/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS66
32
CAC
1934-D 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/17/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS66
31
CAC
1928 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/17/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS66
42
1919 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/11/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS65
7
ICG
ICG
Sponsored
1931-S 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/11/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS65
6
1931-S 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/11/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS65
4
1936-D 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/11/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS65
6
CAC
1936 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/17/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS65
28
1935-S 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/11/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS64
6
CAC
1926-D 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/17/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS63
24
US Coins and Jewelry
US Coins and Jewelry
Sponsored
CAC
1919-S 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/17/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
NGC AU58
24
1937-D 5c 3 Legs, FS-901 MS

Auction Ends: 8/11/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS XF40
4
CAC
1913-S 5c Buffalo, Type 2 MS

Auction Ends: 8/17/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS G6
16
1913 5c Buffalo, Type 1 MS

Buy Now: $400.00

Seller - Stack's Marketplace
NGC MS66
16
1913 5c Buffalo, Type 1 MS

Buy Now: $200.00

Seller - Stack's Marketplace
PCGS MS65
9
1913-D 5c Buffalo, Type 1 MS

Buy Now: $775.00

Seller - Stack's Marketplace
NGC MS66
9
Sponsored
1913-D 5c Buffalo, Type 1 MS

Buy Now: $375.00

Seller - Stack's Marketplace
NGC MS65
12
1913-S 5c Buffalo, Type 1 MS

Buy Now: $825.00

Seller - Stack's Marketplace
PCGS MS65
7
1913-S 5c Buffalo, Type 1 MS

Buy Now: $185.00

Seller - Stack's Marketplace
PCGS AU58
6
1913-S 5c Buffalo, Type 2 MS

Buy Now: $625.00

Seller - Stack's Marketplace
NGC AU53
12
1915 5c MS

Buy Now: $2,000.00

Seller - Stack's Marketplace
PCGS MS67
22
1916 5c MS

Buy Now: $175.00

Seller - Eagle Eye Rare Coins
PCGS MS64
19
CAC
CAC
Sponsored
1916 5c Doubled Die Obverse MS

Buy Now: $12,500.00

Seller - Stack's Marketplace
PCGS VF20
15
1 2